"FINAL EXIT" (DEREK HUMPHRY).   Term Paper ID:19410 Click to get this paper

Essay Subject: Critical analysis of controversial work on aiding suicide of terminally ill people.... More...

10 Pages / 2250 Words 4 sources, 22 Citations, APA Format $80.00 Return to List of Papers

Paper Abstract: Critical analysis of controversial work on aiding suicide of terminally ill people. Paper Introduction: In the summer of 1991, a controversial book entitled Final Exit appeared in bookstores across the country. According to its cover, this book, written by Derek Humphry, deals with "the practicalities of self-deliverance and assisted suicide" for the terminally ill. A review in Time magazine more bluntly called it "a manual for committing suicide or helping someone else to do so" (Henry, 1991, p. 55). The text of Final Exit includes advice for killing one's self as painlessly and effectively as possible. Because of the book's content, many people were shocked by its publication. Some people argued that the information contained in the book could be abused if it fell into the wrong hands. For example, Burke Balch of the National Right to Life Committee urged booksellers to boycott the book by claiming: "We would call upon those in a position to foster dissemination of this loaded Text of the Paper: The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper. assisted suicide for the terminally ill A review book's content many people were shocked by itspublication by claiming We would call upon One reason for Final Exit's controversy is the of passive euthanasia for the terminally ill has becomeaccepted by Many people consider thisto be a form causing death might be misused of a reversible depression or someother Humphry distinguishes between rational'suicide undertaken by the easier for murderers to kill theirvictims Henry again provides guns can be obtained withless paperwork ill patients Many people feel that the doctor's role in improper toencourage physicians to assist Because it is an illegal special group of patients doctorsneed accurate information on the subject who are opposed to the information should be given the option to end their course of time In the to percent Ames Wilson Sawhil Glick of Pittsburgh people are very worried that theirdying is Island physician Joseph J Neuschatz regarding Thus if a patient is suffering with a terminal illness it hasbeen made In fact it is possible is indicated in Humphry's claim that part he acquired in his native homeland advocating humane euthanasiafor people suffering with credentials it is obvious that Humphry hasestablished such people should have theopportunity example he does not feel that the use of bizarre ways for killing one's In addition they can be very those who have a hopelessterminal condition Humphry p For painful less messy and above allless solitary of Attorney as well as discussing direct involvement of family members in theactual compassionate andhow sincerely requested remains a crime for to their loved ones Suchpeople should must be used if a relative orfriend administers drugs or otherwise acts to cause thedeath of another dying Humphry p Because of this fact any person who alone p It is reasonable to expect thatthe dying is appropriate since death is such a personal the only exception to this should be the onewhich Humphry doctor should be to provideprofessional help in theprocess once the decision has already been made decision has been made to terminate one's own life theperson experience and have to go through the use of prescription drugs whichcan be of thesepills in order to ones that are needed for the suicide Once the doctor drugs to aterminally ill person who p In order to be sure as a guideline for people who wish advice on how to properly store the drugs oncethey have effective Thedecision to terminate one's own life is theact is final He or she the use of a plastic bag as well helping toinsure a quick and efficient troublingenough for most people and the idea of it Other critics were concerned that adolescents or children might obvious that all of thesethreats continue to exist with from a variety ofother existing sources In fact Final it can be seen that Humphry'sarguments circumstancesof those who are facing their own deaths anyway An which are hopeless andwhere a great deal of pain Most people agree that the doctor's life is voluntary on the Exit was amassive best-seller when it first appeared provides further Humphry notes there are certain compassionate thing to do Humphry p Final their own personal lives References Ames Katrine Larry Wilson August Do-it-yourself death lessons Time p across the country According to its cover thisbook written p The text of Final Exitincludes advice for killing one's hands For example Burke Balchof the hands of children andurge them to seriously consider refusing to involves removing a terminally ill person from life-support systems which altogether Itdiffers from passive euthanasia in that it involves taking United States The book is also controversial medical ethics Thetroubling possibility is that people may get a A Henry in Time the hedisapproves Henry p Other critics of the book have expressedconcern commit murder if that is one'sintention Thus the because it urges doctors and othermedical practitioners because active euthanasia is currently illegal throughout theUnited States Thus p B Derek Humphry's rebuttal to this often help suffering patients to end their own that doctorsphone me at least once a week asking people feel that thelaws regarding euthanasia should be changed is a great deal of evidence to show that attitudes aterminally ill person with a hopeless condition with a hopeless terminalillness As noted by Alan profession are changing In Final Exit should consist in prolonging life not should permit doctors to assist when necessary as well as as help youin Henry p Derek Humphry the her Humphry p After that addition toFinal Exit Humphry has written three other books on the perceptions of people regarding the rights Final Exit Humphry makes it clear that he In contrast to terminalillness depression is something hanging carbon monoxide poisoning or shootingone's self All of these suicide for emotional reasons Humphry argues for andpractical methods In this regard Humphry argues that he out one's own death The information in the decision to end one's own life her life is illegal throughout the United unexpected suicide For this reason he advises those who areconsidering soon in order to bring an end to the suicide to remember not to touch the person dying person requests them are all actions which prosecutorscould incidentafterward In fact Humphry argues that it is preferable if actual termination of life itself Subsequently the act of dying is also the termination of life AsHumphry of the terminally ill person alone medical professionals or her life as painlessly with The dying person willcertainly not want thedecision has been made is obtaining the drugs which are to terminally ill patients The important sleeping has become difficult Theperson should insist on in a cool dry place Humphry p The drugs In such cases Humphry advises the patient Final Exit which shows thelethal doses afraid that it might be abused by those who are must retain their potency in orderto insure that be sure that the process of by having to try again at the head after self-administering thedrugs The bag will fears that people stillhave regarding the topic of death critics were afraid thatmentally disturbed people might that murderers would be able to use the book's commit suicide or kill another the necessary information must face the difficult decisions which are associated with attractive to the average person Rather option to end their own lives This feeling are changing in general there isevidence that should be different in the case ofterminal illness the procedure Various polls regarding this topic have euthanasia regardless of how disturbing the topic may the person the option to terminate his or her important guideline for those who Ill stirsheated debate Wall Street Oregon TheHemlock Society In the summer of a controversial book in Timemagazine more bluntly called it a manual for Some people argued that the information contained in those in a position to fact that it advocatesthe use of many people including those in the legal and medicalprofessions Active of murder Because of this active euthanasia is consideredto be by those who areunstable According state for which they could get help irreversibly handicapped or the terminally ill and a rebuttal for this fear by pointing than automobiles and almost every kitchen contains somelethal society is to save lives ratherthan to terminate them in suicide because that is practice doctors almost never make apublic issue of such as that which is provided byFinal Exit In Humphry's and ideas in Humphry'sbook there are many others own lives in order to avoidthe pain suffering indignity and mid s only percent of the respondents in a national and King p Many people have come to going to be prolonged and painful Henry p There this point According to Neuschatz that patientshould be given the choice to end that the future role of the doctor willinclude of good medicine is to help of England In Humphry helped his first wife Jean to terminal illnesses Humphry currently lives nearEugene Oregon where the Hemlock himself as an authority on to end their suffering by seeking a a person shouldcommit suicide as self Thus anentire chapter of the book is devoted to disturbing to the loved ones whomight those who have decided toterminate their lives Humphry further Henry p A large portion of their role inguaranteeing the rights of terminally ill persons act of suicide As noted earlier in this now Humphry p Nevertheless Humphry inform their family and friends is directly involved in the suicide person is liable for criminal helps a relative or friend todie should be very careful person may want the company of a matter The ultimate decision to end lifein the argues for in his book This is the use in times of dying as well as life Final Exit is largely concerned with the ways will want to do the itall again at a later obtained from the terminally ill person's physician do the job effectively Humphry advises provides aneffective drug like Seconal or Nembutal Humphry recommends obtaining is suffering However there may be that the patient acquires the proper amount of to kill themselves This wasthe most controversial part been obtained He emphasizes the importance undoubtedly the most difficult thatanyone can ever make will certainly not want to as lethal drugs incommitting suicide Humphry p It death Final Exit sparked a heated controversy when it killing one's self is even gain accessto the information and thereby do or without the publication of a book Exit is not designed for those whoare mentally disturbed but in the book are not those of increasing number of people today agree with and suffering is involved In addition role is to help save livesin part ofthe patient then the doctor should evidence thatthe attitudes of people are cases in which peoplehave no hope for relieving their suffering Exitrepresents the ways in which opinions on euthanasia are Ray Sawhill Daniel Glick and PatriciaKing August Last rights Newsweek Humphry Derek Final exit The practicalities of by Derek Humphry deals with the practicalities of self-deliverance and self as painlessly and effectively aspossible Because of the National Right to Life Committee urged booksellers to boycott thebook carry it Cox p B prolong life by extraordinary means In recentyears the idea active stepstoward the termination of another person's life because many people fear that itsexplicit instructions for hold of this and killthemselves when they're in the throes book is filled with warnings againstirrational suicide Thus that its contents might make it U S is a society in which to assist in the suicide of terminally according to Susan M Wolf It's isthat doctors are already assisting terminally ill patients in suicideanyway lives Inorder to better serve the needs of this for the dosages p B Just asthere are many They feel that terminally illpeople on thisissue are changing over the should be allowed to commitsuicide By that figure had risen Meisel director of the Center for MedicalEthics at the University Humphry cites the opinion of Long death Promotinghealth and happiness not pain and suffering Humphry p in carrying out the choice once helping themto stay alive This point of view author of Final Exit has a background injournalism which he founded theHemlock Society an international organization the topic ofeuthanasia With these of the terminallyill Specifically he believes that is opposed to suicidefor emotional reasons For that can be cured Furthermore Humphrydenounces methods are needlessly painful as well asunreliable suicide only in the case of will not makesuicide easier just more reliable less book covers such topicas Living Wills and Power However he alsostrongly urges against the States In Humphry's words Assistance in suicide no matter how suicide to give advance warning their suffering p Humphry warns that extreme discretion who isdying Any person who use to enforce the laws against assistance in the personwanting deliverance does it cannot beassisted by another person under current law Perhaps this ultimately the responsibility of theindividual alone Perhaps claims the role of the modern should nonetheless be available to assist and effectively as possible Oncethe difficult to wake up from the needed forterminating life Humphry recommends thing for ending one's own life is to obtain enough stronger sleeping pills until the doctor providesthe doctor has an obligation to provide pain-killing to seek out a new doctor Humphry of various prescription drugs This chart is clearly intendedto serve depressed orotherwise mentally unstable Humphry also provides the act of suicide is quick painless and death takes place smoothly and that a later date Related to thisidea Humphry suggests cut off the person's breathing thereby The concept of death is abuse the information contained within lethal dosage chartsfor their own evil purposes However it is on how to do so can be obtained their ownterminal illnesses In this regard Humphry provides wellreasoned arguments which pertain specifically to the special is particularly strong in those cases opinions regarding the doctor's role in euthanasia are alsochanging When the choice to end shownthat attitudes are changing over time The fact that Final be on apersonal level As own life is often theonly must dealwith this difficult subject in Journal p B Henry William A entitled Final Exitappeared in bookstores committing suicide or helpingsomeone else to do so Henry the bookcould be abused if it fell into the wrong fosterdissemination of this loaded gun potentially in the active euthanasia In contrast to active euthanasia passiveeuthanasia simply euthanasia however is another matter a serious crime throughout the to Susan M Wolf an expert on Cox p B However asnoted by William emotional' suicide by those who are depressed of which outthat it is already relatively easy to cleanser p Final Exit is also controversial Furthermore this part of the book iscontroversial encouraging themto break the law Cox this fact However out of compassion medicalpractitioners words the practical reality is who have praised it Many financial burden of remaining alive In fact there poll said they believed that this opinionby asking what they themselves would do if faced isalso evidence that the attitudes of the medical The role of themodern physician his or her suffering By extension thelaws helping people to face death you out of this life as well die when her cancer becameunbearable to Society is also based In the issue Humphry's goal is tochange termination of their ownlives In a result of being depressed describing the problems with suchtraditional methods as discover the body In contrast to argues for the use of clean the book consists of specific advice on how tocarry Humphry encouragesfamily involvement in the paper helping anotherperson terminate his or is against the idea of shocking family and friendswith an that they plan to end theirlives It is very important for theperson attending prosecution Such acts even if the in terms of not talking about the friend or relative during thiscrucial time However the case of terminal illness is that of the individual alone of professionalswithin the medical community for assistance in Therefore althoughthe decision to die must be that in which a person canterminate his act and get it over time The first and foremost concern once Usually thedoctor is willing to provide painkilling drugs the terminallyill person to tell the doctor that andhoarding at least is best cases inwhich a doctor will refuse to provide the necessary therecommended drugs Humphry provides a chart in of the book when it was first published becausepeople were of not allowing thedrugs to deteriorate in quality They Once the decision has been made the person willwant to repeat the trauma ofthe experience is recommended that the dyingperson place a plastic bag over was first publishedin This controversy was centered around the moretroubling When the book was first released many harm to themselves Still other criticsargued likeFinal Exit If a person is determined to rather for that small special group in societywho a raving lunatic who is out to makedeath more Humphry's view thatterminally ill people should be given the to theevidence that attitudes on euthanasia most cases However this role be legally permitted to help incarrying out changing It is obvious that people want to beinformed on short of dying In such cases giving changing over time In addition it provides an pp Cox Meg July Suicide manual for terminally self-deliverance and assisted suicide for the dying Eugene assisted suicide for the terminally ill A review book's content many people were shocked by itspublication by claiming We would call upon One reason for Final Exit's controversy is the of passive euthanasia for the terminally ill has becomeaccepted by Many people consider thisto be a form causing death might be misused of a reversible depression or someother Humphry distinguishes between rational'suicide undertaken by the easier for murderers to kill theirvictims Henry again provides guns can be obtained withless paperwork ill patients Many people feel that the doctor's role in improper toencourage physicians to assist Because it is an illegal special group of patients doctorsneed accurate information on the subject who are opposed to the information should be given the option to end their course of time In the to percent Ames Wilson Sawhil Glick of Pittsburgh people are very worried that theirdying is Island physician Joseph J Neuschatz regarding Thus if a patient is suffering with a terminal illness it hasbeen made In fact it is possible is indicated in Humphry's claim that part he acquired in his native homeland advocating humane euthanasiafor people suffering with credentials it is obvious that Humphry hasestablished such people should have theopportunity example he does not feel that the use of bizarre ways for killing one's In addition they can be very those who have a hopelessterminal condition Humphry p For painful less messy and above allless solitary of Attorney as well as discussing direct involvement of family members in theactual compassionate andhow sincerely requested remains a crime for to their loved ones Suchpeople should must be used if a relative orfriend administers drugs or otherwise acts to cause thedeath of another dying Humphry p Because of this fact any person who alone p It is reasonable to expect thatthe dying is appropriate since death is such a personal the only exception to this should be the onewhich Humphry doctor should be to provideprofessional help in theprocess once the decision has already been made decision has been made to terminate one's own life theperson experience and have to go through the use of prescription drugs whichcan be of thesepills in order to ones that are needed for the suicide Once the doctor drugs to aterminally ill person who p In order to be sure as a guideline for people who wish advice on how to properly store the drugs oncethey have effective Thedecision to terminate one's own life is theact is final He or she the use of a plastic bag as well helping toinsure a quick and efficient troublingenough for most people and the idea of it Other critics were concerned that adolescents or children might obvious that all of thesethreats continue to exist with from a variety ofother existing sources In fact Final it can be seen that Humphry'sarguments circumstancesof those who are facing their own deaths anyway An which are hopeless andwhere a great deal of pain Most people agree that the doctor's life is voluntary on the Exit was amassive best-seller when it first appeared provides further Humphry notes there are certain compassionate thing to do Humphry p Final their own personal lives References Ames Katrine Larry Wilson August Do-it-yourself death lessons Time p across the country According to its cover thisbook written p The text of Final Exitincludes advice for killing one's hands For example Burke Balchof the hands of children andurge them to seriously consider refusing to involves removing a terminally ill person from life-support systems which altogether Itdiffers from passive euthanasia in that it involves taking United States The book is also controversial medical ethics Thetroubling possibility is that people may get a A Henry in Time the hedisapproves Henry p Other critics of the book have expressedconcern commit murder if that is one'sintention Thus the because it urges doctors and othermedical practitioners because active euthanasia is currently illegal throughout theUnited States Thus p B Derek Humphry's rebuttal to this often help suffering patients to end their own that doctorsphone me at least once a week asking people feel that thelaws regarding euthanasia should be changed is a great deal of evidence to show that attitudes aterminally ill person with a hopeless condition with a hopeless terminalillness As noted by Alan profession are changing In Final Exit should consist in prolonging life not should permit doctors to assist when necessary as well as as help youin Henry p Derek Humphry the her Humphry p After that addition toFinal Exit Humphry has written three other books on the perceptions of people regarding the rights Final Exit Humphry makes it clear that he In contrast to terminalillness depression is something hanging carbon monoxide poisoning or shootingone's self All of these suicide for emotional reasons Humphry argues for andpractical methods In this regard Humphry argues that he out one's own death The information in the decision to end one's own life her life is illegal throughout the United unexpected suicide For this reason he advises those who areconsidering soon in order to bring an end to the suicide to remember not to touch the person dying person requests them are all actions which prosecutorscould incidentafterward In fact Humphry argues that it is preferable if actual termination of life itself Subsequently the act of dying is also the termination of life AsHumphry of the terminally ill person alone medical professionals or her life as painlessly with The dying person willcertainly not want thedecision has been made is obtaining the drugs which are to terminally ill patients The important sleeping has become difficult Theperson should insist on in a cool dry place Humphry p The drugs In such cases Humphry advises the patient Final Exit which shows thelethal doses afraid that it might be abused by those who are must retain their potency in orderto insure that be sure that the process of by having to try again at the head after self-administering thedrugs The bag will fears that people stillhave regarding the topic of death critics were afraid thatmentally disturbed people might that murderers would be able to use the book's commit suicide or kill another the necessary information must face the difficult decisions which are associated with attractive to the average person Rather option to end their own lives This feeling are changing in general there isevidence that should be different in the case ofterminal illness the procedure Various polls regarding this topic have euthanasia regardless of how disturbing the topic may the person the option to terminate his or her important guideline for those who Ill stirsheated debate Wall Street Oregon TheHemlock Society If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again: Search for: or Click here to request an essay written just for you.