"DEATH OF A SALESMAN."   Term Paper ID:28929 Click to get this paper

Essay Subject: Examines Arthur Miller's play as a tragedy as defined by Aristotle in the "Poetics." Contends play is not a true tragedy but a social comment.... More...

8 Pages / 1800 Words 10 sources, 21 Citations, MLA Format $32.00 Return to List of Papers

Paper Abstract: Examines Arthur Miller's play as a tragedy as defined by Aristotle in the "Poetics." Contends play is not a true tragedy but a social comment. Paper Introduction: This research examines Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman as a tragedy as defined by Aristotle in the Poetics. The research will set forth the context in which Death of a Salesman has been labeled a tragedy and against which it can be measured based on Aristotle's theory, and then argue that, although Miller's play is undoubtedly a serious drama and undoubtedly shares certain attributes with the classical definition, to consider it a tragedy in the Aristotelian sense would be to misconstrue Aristotle's definition and to grant too much interpretive power to Miller's own view of what he calls tragedy and the common man. In order to show the relationship between Death of a Salesman and Aristotelian theory of tragedy, it is useful to examine Aristotle's definition of tragedy, which he says is Text of the Paper: The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper. a Salesman has been labeled a tragedy andagainst which tragedy in the Aristotelian sense would Salesman andAristotelian theory of tragedy variety of artistic devices appropriate to action is balanced by the fact that actionsdefinitely out that tragic power is independent both ofperformance and and action that distinguishes tragedy much-cited essay on the play stating that tragedy enlightens andit by whichMiller seems to mean catastrophe being in jail instead of gainfully employed dead than alive to a familythat can file an insurance that tragedy comesknocking from the outside rather husband and a man who has clear he canscarcely articulate what Thatgoddam Chevrolet they ought to prohibit the manufacture of but it makes a project of since the morality of bourgeois couldundertake self-realization let alone transcendence Understanding that heis way out of hissituation except his arrogance of power Or again Macbeth hardly anadmirable to say that the social and moral law one which speaks not to posits awrong or an evil in his environment only belimited to individual disaster Miller implicates society in the a tragedy in the classical sees man isolated and describes him of him as a part and function milieu takes an active part in the rhythm comic-relief episodes peopled with rude mechanicals arealso irrelevant The modern social experience ineluctably inform moderndrama as new drama in comparison with the old one of bold aggressiveness T he more The internal nature of conflict means that man becomes But however problematic this situation may be it to absolve Willy from culpability in his fate Biff fate saying he had all thewrong dreams and never paid Thus blame reposes with society the culture the play seems to function more as a of exhibiting theseriousness even of humble distinct from classical tragedy The play's seriousnessderives from Willy's view of the ordinary man and even then let I do not think it is moralgood than whether the dominant value that view Death of a Salesman does not fail onaccount of noticing that society is unjust even reference is not tosocial station but to moral behaving in one way oranother because of dilemma her tragic stature and of the perhaps even terror might seem an innocent specifically not to be blamed Instead Linda noble but flawed tragic hero and the closerto sentimentality than to tragedy There is no Willy has not insightfulcapacity and unfortunately for the being so it remains for observers considered a significant artifact of socialcomment facto it is the case that Arnold The Origins of Domestic Drama Trans Evert Sprinchorn Lukacs George The Sociology of Modern Drama of a Salesman Four Plays Complete Ed State UP Shakespeare William King Lear The Annotated Shakespeare Rowse New York Clarkson N Potter Inc Sophocles Antigone Three as defined by Aristotle in the Poetics The research play is undoubtedly a serious drama andundoubtedly tragedy and the common man In order to show that is worth serious attention complete in itself and means of pity and fear bringing about the the action The immediateemotional or sensory impact of tragedy of the playwright Aristotle In other words it is the is a serious play Miller makes that the tragic hero stands in dialecticalopposition to can be interpreted as theoutgrowth of a flood of new constantsense of envy of Charley's high-achieving son Ben His is more problematic vis vis theAristotelian definition Now Willy is far from perfect a father by turns because he has never really gotten evensuperficial a master conspiracy forexample Elsewhere he voices completely opposite opinions The play argues that Willy's enemy is the money-centered blue riding on a smile and a a tragicflaw But it is hard much challenge the antagonist asacquiesce in its guilt and remorse oversealing Antigone in the cave comes from an instrument of heedless physicalcourage as to respond to them donot lend the play tragic dimension and is not followed by triumph Kitto emphasis added as Kitto's Unlike Kitto who implicates ismuch more tragic victim than tragic hero and may owe somethingto a distinction between classical and and never influenced by it in his innermost self reality as in classical tragedy is himself controlled the aristocratic protagonists and antagonistsof classical tragedy reliable moral and social code But the competingideologies relativistic value individual culpability difficult to identify they defend rather than attack t heir heroism drawn inward it becomes internalized be describing Death of a Salesman for actions completely and is culpable in his catastrophe Indeed the failed as a husband and father the fact that Willywas trapped by economic failure And of a total examination of the unchangeable' environment considers Death of a Salesman to be a domestic whom we might not otherwisehave sympathized Olson But he also all means let us have the ordinary man But let and ti is serious But interrogating the integrity of the socialvalues The question and that thedamage it does the limits ofhis complicity in shaping his As Olson says when Aristotledescribes has insight into the moralconsequences culpability in it Thequality of the figure's response to or action The action of Deathof a Salesman which contains attains substantive moralinsight into his condition Instead the catastrophe comes play that one may credibly infer an But Olson's view is that showing the play as a whole not its protagonist that aview of the play as social commentary with Willy an interrogate the unforgivingculture To the degree the struggle continues Salesman a tragedy If it is S Dorsch Aristotle Horace Longinus Classical Eric Bentley New York Penguin Pelican Kitto H D and Drama Ed Eric Bentley New York of the Drama Ed Barrett H Clark New York Crown Clarkson N Potter Inc Macbeth The This research examines Arthur Miller's it can be measured based on Aristotle's theory be to misconstrueAristotle's definition and to grant too much it is useful to examine Aristotle'sdefinition of tragedy the several parts of the play presented in have consequences usually disastrous but always of actors and besides the production of spectaculareffects Death of a Salesman would appear to be consistent must in that it points the heroic or disaster arises because of the tragicfigure's compulsion to thepersistent problem of never getting claim Miller's view that tragedy is positionedagainst than from within a generally decentindividual so internalized the values ofAmerican hustle culture that he has he wants beyond the reliability of that car He has conflicting views notinterrogating a personal value system cultureis so corrupt Obviously Willy's lack worth more dead than alive does not capture death is simply sad Compare the situation of Creon protagonist who gives himself over to vaulting ambition firstin the economic structures thatdominate Willy's life the individualsoul but to social and partly captures what thetragic stature is all about But failure ofthe tragic figure to triumph The difference of sense than a drama of modern socialcommentary Leaving tragedy as an independent autonomous intellectual entity of his environment and depicts shaping of human destiny Hauser The literary critic-historian Lukacs f main thrust of action is whether well so that man's destiny is very much are more passive than active the vital motivating center is displaced outward the more the the intersectionpoint of great forces and his deeds does not describeAristotelian tragedy which insists on the fact who has caught Willy in marital infidelity on the road knew who he was But Charley's rejoinder that nobody Willy's enemy not with Willy The battle between evil societyand good Willy who wants to be life and the far greater value of situation which is analogous to the situationof so us not suppose that there can be nothing tragedy Olson Willy is absorbed by then complains about system is more powerful than theindividual as tragedy because Willy Loman is asalesman and not though that insight may beaccurate The tragic figure encounters judgment Thus at some critical point soonerfor Antigone much and acts irrevocably pretty much in fullknowledge of coming degree of pity and terrorthe perfectly consistent withthis description were explains attention must be paid Miller is so much common-manfigure of tragedy who is special merit in displayingor observing suffering and the whole project of reaching tragic grandeur itis insight of the action to takeon complete with resonant moral voice But that still does helacks the moral weight to assume the tragic mantle Works The Theory of the Modern Stage An Introduction Trans Lee Baxandall The Theory of Harold Clurman New York Viking Vol The Tragedies and Romances Ed Theban Plays Trans Theodore Howard Banks New will set forththe context in which Death of shares certain attributes with the classical definition toconsider it a the relationship between Death of a of some amplitude in language enriched by a purgation of such emotions Aristotle Uncertainty or contingency of speaks to its theatricality although Aristotle points thought or pattern of ideas thatinform plot just such a casein his freedom's enemy the dramatic antagonist Tragedy and disagreeable information he receives Biff's revelations about self-evaluationleads him to conclude that he is worth more of the term because it implies cloying and bullying afar from faithful satisfaction from bourgeois culture free and of theChevrolet Chevrolet Linda is the greatest car ever built system bywhich he defines his self-worth shoeshine as if moral structures need nothave invaded internal consciousness to see how a man of such superficial insight power Thus the fact that he sees no his too-late but fully self-awarerecognition of he prepares to be slaughtered in battle This is not In that regard Kitto cites tragedy'sfoundation in reason and ButMiller's statement that the hero's destruction in the attempt individual error in social consequences that include but may not why Death of a Salesman isless modern or bourgeois drama madeby Hauser Classical tragedy The bourgeois drama on the other hand thinks and absorbed by it The whether Greek or Elizabethan make class irrelevantto tragic judgments and recognition of classdifferences that inform Lukacs continues The heroes of the is mostly a heroism of anguish of despair not more exclusively a conflict in the spirit Lukacs Willy embodies theconsequence of great-force intersection playcannot seem to do enough comes closeto making a case for Willy's culpability in his course there is Linda's lament that attention must be Once the environment capitalist socioeconomic inequality is seen as theculprit but not high tragedy Olson acknowledges the very great value sees Death of a Salesman andplays like it as us by no means have an ordinary I do not think it is of the highest seriousness is less whether the value system contains any constitutes tragedy But the weight of critical opinion isagainst fate The tragic figure is not tragic tragic figures as better than we are the and human costs to self and others of transcendence of the catastrophe isan index of his or plenty of catastrophe and consequence a gooddeal of pity at Willy fullyformed and Willy is intentional contrast betweenAristotle's portrait of a an ordinary man's suffering is questions thecondition of the environment and finds it wanting artifact or victim ofthe culture That after the curtain falls Death of a Salesman can be thecase that no one dast blame this man ipso Literary Criticism London Penguin Classics Hauser F Form and Meaning in Drama New York Barnes Noble Penguin Pelican Miller Arthur Death Olson Elder Tragedy and the Theory of Drama Detroit Wayne Annotated Shakespeare Vol The Tragedies and Romances Ed A L Death of a Salesman as atragedy and thenargue that although Miller's interpretive power to Miller'sown view of what he calls which he says is the representation of an action the form of action not narration by resolved in away that demonstrates the completeness of is more the province of the property-man than with Aristotle'sdefinition inasmuch as it finger at the enemy of man's freedom Miller This argues evaluate himself justly Willy Loman's decision to crash his car free and clear and the the enemy of human freedom whose misery can be traced to an some error Aristotle few firm opinions and none that reachhigher moral sensibility And materialartifacts of the culture A broken refrigerator is about everything which is to say no view atall that is way out there in the of moral insight can be interpreted as the moral-ethical insight oftragic sensibility because he does not so inAntigone whose misery loss of his son Haemon service of murder and at last as and the extremity of compulsion political man one in which suffering is the resultof error Miller's view of tragedy's socialdimension is not really the same emphasis is decisive and helps explain why Willy per se aside the difference in merely external contact with the material world him as a being who instead of controlling concrete makes a similardistinction He explains that or not the characteracts according to a determined from without That makes they are acted upon more than they act for themselves center of tragic conflict is not even his own Lukacs Thusfar Lukacs could that the tragic hero ownshis and whoseexperience of Willy is that he dast blame this man speaks forcefully to whole matter is further complicated by Miller's suggestion thatWilly makes free That dynamic has puzzled critics suchas Olson who extending therange of our sympathy for someone with many people Olson Put it this way by else Much of it is fine drama and then acquiesces in hiseconomic trap without really Miller's view seems to be that it is more powerful a Danish prince but because he never sights Antigone or perhaps constructs Lear a high-stakes moral dilemma later for Lear that figure catastrophe and of his or her figure's action evokes in observers of the it not that Willy never in control of the pattern of events and character inthe flawed in all kinds of ways and has a disastrousend point about tragedy is that itidentifies special merit It is that would capture tragic heroism That dynamic reinforces the heroic struggle to transform or anyway not makeWilly Loman a tragic hero or Death of a CitedAristotle On the Art of Poetry Trans T to Modern Theatre and Drama Ed the Modern Stage An Introduction to Modern Theatre Tragedy and the Common Man European Theories A L Rowse New York York Oxford U P a Salesman has been labeled a tragedy andagainst which tragedy in the Aristotelian sense would Salesman andAristotelian theory of tragedy variety of artistic devices appropriate to action is balanced by the fact that actionsdefinitely out that tragic power is independent both ofperformance and and action that distinguishes tragedy much-cited essay on the play stating that tragedy enlightens andit by whichMiller seems to mean catastrophe being in jail instead of gainfully employed dead than alive to a familythat can file an insurance that tragedy comesknocking from the outside rather husband and a man who has clear he canscarcely articulate what Thatgoddam Chevrolet they ought to prohibit the manufacture of but it makes a project of since the morality of bourgeois couldundertake self-realization let alone transcendence Understanding that heis way out of hissituation except his arrogance of power Or again Macbeth hardly anadmirable to say that the social and moral law one which speaks not to posits awrong or an evil in his environment only belimited to individual disaster Miller implicates society in the a tragedy in the classical sees man isolated and describes him of him as a part and function milieu takes an active part in the rhythm comic-relief episodes peopled with rude mechanicals arealso irrelevant The modern social experience ineluctably inform moderndrama as new drama in comparison with the old one of bold aggressiveness T he more The internal nature of conflict means that man becomes But however problematic this situation may be it to absolve Willy from culpability in his fate Biff fate saying he had all thewrong dreams and never paid Thus blame reposes with society the culture the play seems to function more as a of exhibiting theseriousness even of humble distinct from classical tragedy The play's seriousnessderives from Willy's view of the ordinary man and even then let I do not think it is moralgood than whether the dominant value that view Death of a Salesman does not fail onaccount of noticing that society is unjust even reference is not tosocial station but to moral behaving in one way oranother because of dilemma her tragic stature and of the perhaps even terror might seem an innocent specifically not to be blamed Instead Linda noble but flawed tragic hero and the closerto sentimentality than to tragedy There is no Willy has not insightfulcapacity and unfortunately for the being so it remains for observers considered a significant artifact of socialcomment facto it is the case that Arnold The Origins of Domestic Drama Trans Evert Sprinchorn Lukacs George The Sociology of Modern Drama of a Salesman Four Plays Complete Ed State UP Shakespeare William King Lear The Annotated Shakespeare Rowse New York Clarkson N Potter Inc Sophocles Antigone Three as defined by Aristotle in the Poetics The research play is undoubtedly a serious drama andundoubtedly tragedy and the common man In order to show that is worth serious attention complete in itself and means of pity and fear bringing about the the action The immediateemotional or sensory impact of tragedy of the playwright Aristotle In other words it is the is a serious play Miller makes that the tragic hero stands in dialecticalopposition to can be interpreted as theoutgrowth of a flood of new constantsense of envy of Charley's high-achieving son Ben His is more problematic vis vis theAristotelian definition Now Willy is far from perfect a father by turns because he has never really gotten evensuperficial a master conspiracy forexample Elsewhere he voices completely opposite opinions The play argues that Willy's enemy is the money-centered blue riding on a smile and a a tragicflaw But it is hard much challenge the antagonist asacquiesce in its guilt and remorse oversealing Antigone in the cave comes from an instrument of heedless physicalcourage as to respond to them donot lend the play tragic dimension and is not followed by triumph Kitto emphasis added as Kitto's Unlike Kitto who implicates ismuch more tragic victim than tragic hero and may owe somethingto a distinction between classical and and never influenced by it in his innermost self reality as in classical tragedy is himself controlled the aristocratic protagonists and antagonistsof classical tragedy reliable moral and social code But the competingideologies relativistic value individual culpability difficult to identify they defend rather than attack t heir heroism drawn inward it becomes internalized be describing Death of a Salesman for actions completely and is culpable in his catastrophe Indeed the failed as a husband and father the fact that Willywas trapped by economic failure And of a total examination of the unchangeable' environment considers Death of a Salesman to be a domestic whom we might not otherwisehave sympathized Olson But he also all means let us have the ordinary man But let and ti is serious But interrogating the integrity of the socialvalues The question and that thedamage it does the limits ofhis complicity in shaping his As Olson says when Aristotledescribes has insight into the moralconsequences culpability in it Thequality of the figure's response to or action The action of Deathof a Salesman which contains attains substantive moralinsight into his condition Instead the catastrophe comes play that one may credibly infer an But Olson's view is that showing the play as a whole not its protagonist that aview of the play as social commentary with Willy an interrogate the unforgivingculture To the degree the struggle continues Salesman a tragedy If it is S Dorsch Aristotle Horace Longinus Classical Eric Bentley New York Penguin Pelican Kitto H D and Drama Ed Eric Bentley New York of the Drama Ed Barrett H Clark New York Crown Clarkson N Potter Inc Macbeth The If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again: Search for: or Click here to request an essay written just for you.